Doctor Who Series 3: Difference between revisions
JoshuaJSlone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
JoshuaJSlone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 95: | Line 95: | ||
If there's one curiosity I'm left with, it's that Sally got the TARDIS key hanging from a statue's hand. Later on it's revealed the statue's want inside the TARDIS, and they try attacking her as she's trying to use the key to get in. So why didn't they just use the key? Did they not understand its importance until hearing the Doctor talk about it on the DVD? | If there's one curiosity I'm left with, it's that Sally got the TARDIS key hanging from a statue's hand. Later on it's revealed the statue's want inside the TARDIS, and they try attacking her as she's trying to use the key to get in. So why didn't they just use the key? Did they not understand its importance until hearing the Doctor talk about it on the DVD? | ||
--- | |||
11: Utopia [[September 21]], [[2007]] | |||
(First watched 2007-09-21) That was pretty exceptional... Not just for the events of the episode itself, but for how they play into the larger tapestry. | |||
Jack Harkness: In Britain, by this point they'd have had the entire [[Torchwood Series 1|first series of Torchwood]] finished, but we've only had two episodes here. So some of what is here presented as new material may have been old hat; I don't know. But his age... wow. I assumed he hadn't been back in the "present" long, but come to find he's lived on Earth for nearly 140 years? That's pretty crazy, but does give more of an explanation as to why he seems to fit in so well in modern Cardiff. It also makes him seem really Doctor-obsessed to have been waiting to meet him again for so long. They only knew each other for what, 5 episodes? I guess he wasn't planning on accidentally ending up in the 19th century, though, so it's not like he planned the waiting 140 years bit. | |||
The Master: I know this is an old character returned, but I'm not very familiar with him. I believe he was in the 1996 movie, but I recall jack-all about that. I thought part of that plot had to do with him running out of regenerations, though? Anyway, seeing his whimsy after regeneration makes for an interesting comparison to The Doctor, though. | |||
That crazy severed hand: I must've missed something, how did it end up there in the future? It didn't seem Jack was carrying something that bulky, and anyway I think it was around before they recovered the TARDIS. It seemed as though through amazing coincidence it had survived 100 trillion years and ended up in the same place? That would be far-fetched even for this program, though, so I must've missed something. | |||
100 trillion years: Isn't that... quite a bit? I'm not Mr. Cosmology, but considering the sort of end-of-the-universe theories I've read of, I'd think there should not only not be stars around, but matter as we know it. Apart from that, 100 trillion years and humans still look just as they do now? | |||
--- | --- | ||
Revision as of 01:29, 22 September 2007
X: The Runaway Bride July 6, 2007
(First watched 2007-07-06) Wow, this episode never let up. Feeling like 2 episodes in the space of 1.5, and existing as a mostly standalone episode between companions, this felt very movie-like. Mysterious transportations, TARDIS flying down the street, draining the Thames! It kinda bugged me that a few series back the Doctor was agonizing over the decision of committing Dalek genocide, but he didn't seem very concerned about exterminating the Racnoss tonight. Of course, he did... change... between then and now.
---
01: Smith and Jones July 6, 2007
(First watched 2007-07-06) Not a bad introduction for Martha Jones. Good thing she's made out to be a bit less clueless about things; Rose was used as a reintroduction to the series, but it's not needed again just two years later. Those Judoon rhinos looked pretty nice; my expectations were pretty low after the goofy-looking Slitheen. Great use of a bit of audience-unexpected time travel trickery at the beginning/end.
---
02: The Shakespeare Code July 13, 2007
(First watched 2007-07-13) Heh. Well, Harry Potter and Back to the Future references certainly weren't something seen in 60s Doctor Who. "Wait until you read book seven. I cried."
---
(First watched 2007-07-20 and -25) I found this episode... unbelievable. In an allegorical sense I can appreciate that the people of the undercity were wasting their life away trying to get from one place to another, but... to have the entire upper city die off and noone notices? That they very quickly get used to taking decades to go from one place to another, when noone is actually reaching above after all? That nobody could figure out a way to open the ceiling? That there were giant devolved crab people living down there, somehow eating enough people to sustain a population even before there was the permanent traffic jam? That people already had the easy technology to create essentially free food and energy, but wanted to take a years-long trip to get a job? That even if the believed rules of traffic worked properly, it would actually be that hard to get a group of three or greater when EVERYONE wanted to get in the fast lane?
The old couple dying in the intro reminded me of the folks in the American Gothic painting. I wonder if that was intentional. If so I don't see that it was supposed to mean anything...
On a plus, the Doctor's trip down the levels dropping down and going through various odd peoples' vehicles was quite cool.
---
04: Daleks in Manhattan July 27, 2007
(First watched 2007-07-27) I'm getting tired of the Daleks, frankly. They're a cool enemy, but in that they were supposed to be wiped from time and yet this is the... fourth random run-in the Doctor has had with them in less than three years, it seems a bit much.
Perhaps I missed something, but after the "One trip to the past, one trip to the future" thing, there wasn't an excuse given for this third trip with Martha, or admission that it's going to be a more lasting thing.
---
05: Evolution of the Daleks August 3, 2007
(First watched 2007-08-03) Interesting how the combination of one evil Dalek and one nasty lackey human ended up making for such a progressive human Dalek, though of course I knew things wouldn't work out.
For a guy who just a couple years ago was telling Rose it was OK to allow disembodied spirits to control corpses in 19th century England, the Doctor sure seemed sure tonight that there was no way for a group of human Daleks to live on the planet.
I like Martha, but less so when this whole Doctor/Rose/Martha thing comes up. She seems so worried about whether the Doctor considers her a substitute that it diminishes her sense of self-worth and makes her seem weaker.
---
06: The Lazarus Experiment August 10, 2007
(First watched 2007-08-10) OK, so finally Martha Jones is permanent. Well, as permanent as companions get.
The CG Lazarus monster was interesting... it was easily discernable as CG, but as far as completely inhuman CG monsters go, it's about as good as I've seen for a television show.
Interesting that the Doctor gives speeches about how long life isn't always great, and the natural lifespan is worth respecting... when clearly as a Time Lord he's into cheating death. And inevitably if the show is around (in some form or another) a decade or two from now, they're going to start to hit the limit of even how many regenerations he should be getting and write in some workaround.
Spinal Tap reference hurf burf.
---
(First watched 2007-08-18) Beyond the near-real-time gimmick, this episode didn't do much for me.
---
08: Human Nature August 25, 2007
(First watched 2007-08-25) Combined for the next episode.
---
09: The Family of Blood September 7, 2007
(First watched 2007-09-07) Nice episodes. I'm glad the conclusion had time to boil with a second episode; I was afraid things were going to get quickly resolved in the last five minutes of the first.
I'm reminded somewhat of Enterprise episode Similitude, in that for some reason there's a temporary alternate version of a character created to aid the original, making for identity problems and ethical questions. In this case, John Smith has to try to deal with the fact that what he perceives as his entire life is just a fiction, what he thought were dreams were the reality, and that he essentially has to die to allow the Doctor to live.
The notebook and sketches John Smith kept of his dreams of past adventures and selves was too cool.
Baines--I quite enjoyed the crazy face his actor used for the alien-possessed version. What a sniff.
Complaints... doesn't a device that completely rewrites genetics seem... too convenient to have just been sitting around? Considering he's been faced with various people trying to prolong their lives through gruesome means, people with strange physical disorders, that he himself should be running out of regenerations soon, that he's supposedly the last Time Lord, and that he worries about his companions growing old and dying while he doesn't... doesn't it seem that this device would be able to take care of such problems?
Damn, the Doctor seems to go for cruel and unusual punishment! Spiting the people who wanted eternal life, he puts them in eternal imprisonment? And not just any old eternal imprisonment, fancy shit like sticking people in mirrors.
---
10: Blink September 14, 2007
(First watched 2007-09-14) God, what a great episode. The nonlinear story elements were fantastic, and the concept of statues that can only move when not being looked at is a genuinely creepy one.
This episode was written by Steven Moffat, who also wrote last series's "The Girl in the Fireplace", so this pretty much cements him as my favorite writer of the show.
If there's one curiosity I'm left with, it's that Sally got the TARDIS key hanging from a statue's hand. Later on it's revealed the statue's want inside the TARDIS, and they try attacking her as she's trying to use the key to get in. So why didn't they just use the key? Did they not understand its importance until hearing the Doctor talk about it on the DVD?
---
11: Utopia September 21, 2007
(First watched 2007-09-21) That was pretty exceptional... Not just for the events of the episode itself, but for how they play into the larger tapestry.
Jack Harkness: In Britain, by this point they'd have had the entire first series of Torchwood finished, but we've only had two episodes here. So some of what is here presented as new material may have been old hat; I don't know. But his age... wow. I assumed he hadn't been back in the "present" long, but come to find he's lived on Earth for nearly 140 years? That's pretty crazy, but does give more of an explanation as to why he seems to fit in so well in modern Cardiff. It also makes him seem really Doctor-obsessed to have been waiting to meet him again for so long. They only knew each other for what, 5 episodes? I guess he wasn't planning on accidentally ending up in the 19th century, though, so it's not like he planned the waiting 140 years bit.
The Master: I know this is an old character returned, but I'm not very familiar with him. I believe he was in the 1996 movie, but I recall jack-all about that. I thought part of that plot had to do with him running out of regenerations, though? Anyway, seeing his whimsy after regeneration makes for an interesting comparison to The Doctor, though.
That crazy severed hand: I must've missed something, how did it end up there in the future? It didn't seem Jack was carrying something that bulky, and anyway I think it was around before they recovered the TARDIS. It seemed as though through amazing coincidence it had survived 100 trillion years and ended up in the same place? That would be far-fetched even for this program, though, so I must've missed something.
100 trillion years: Isn't that... quite a bit? I'm not Mr. Cosmology, but considering the sort of end-of-the-universe theories I've read of, I'd think there should not only not be stars around, but matter as we know it. Apart from that, 100 trillion years and humans still look just as they do now?
---