654
edits
Doctor Who Season 6: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
no edit summary
JoshuaJSlone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
JoshuaJSlone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 116: | Line 116: | ||
*''[[1969]] [[June 21]]'' | *''[[1969]] [[June 21]]'' | ||
(First watched 2024-05-17, ) When they show up in a ~World War I environment, I was thinking about how the time of the episode was closer to WWI than it was to me watching it. However, it now seems like it's not really WWI at all. But a "1917 Zone" full of captured people who've had their minds messed with. | (First watched 2024-05-17, -19, -21, -22, -24, -26, -28, -29, -31, 06-02) When they show up in a ~World War I environment, I was thinking about how the time of the episode was closer to WWI than it was to me watching it. However, it now seems like it's not really WWI at all. But a "1917 Zone" full of captured people who've had their minds messed with. | ||
Several episodes in, I am a little unclear on EXACTLY how the world they're in is put together, but in practice it reminds me of a Time Odyssey book I read where different parts of Earth were how they were at different points in Earth's history. In this case they do seem to be using a TARDIS-like time/space machine to drop people off in the different zones, but it feels more like they're in an entirely not-Earth environment and the borders between zones just display fake horizons from either side. | Several episodes in, I am a little unclear on EXACTLY how the world they're in is put together, but in practice it reminds me of a Time Odyssey book I read where different parts of Earth were how they were at different points in Earth's history. In this case they do seem to be using a TARDIS-like time/space machine to drop people off in the different zones, but it feels more like they're in an entirely not-Earth environment and the borders between zones just display fake horizons from either side. | ||
| Line 123: | Line 123: | ||
OK, so now we hear what the plan is and... it doesn't make much sense! OK, this group of aliens wants to take over the galaxy. And the best warriors they know of are humans. But seems like 18th, 19th, early 20th century soldiers would be pretty behind the times? Unless they would then have them using more advanced gear? And they'd have a very finite supply of humans taken from historical wars, at least without completely screwing up history and thus making the fighters from later wars possibly not even exist. And with this finite supply of humans they want to take over a hundred or a thousand planets or whatever they said and thus rule the galaxy? | OK, so now we hear what the plan is and... it doesn't make much sense! OK, this group of aliens wants to take over the galaxy. And the best warriors they know of are humans. But seems like 18th, 19th, early 20th century soldiers would be pretty behind the times? Unless they would then have them using more advanced gear? And they'd have a very finite supply of humans taken from historical wars, at least without completely screwing up history and thus making the fighters from later wars possibly not even exist. And with this finite supply of humans they want to take over a hundred or a thousand planets or whatever they said and thus rule the galaxy? | ||
So in episode 9 the Doctor decides there's no choice but to call on the Time Lords, since only they can help get the kidnapped humans back to their original places and times. BUT since he's a fugitive from them, he doesn't want to stick around for it. So he sends a message, then tries to run for the TARDIS like a bat out of hell before they can show up, though other people slow him down. So for practical purposes, if he thought he could make an escape in the TARDIS, I'm wondering why he didn't wait until he was back to it, send his message, and be gone two seconds later with a pull on the controls? | |||
As a Star Trek fan it's kind of funny that the Time Lords essentially put the Doctor on trial for violating the Prime Directive. Their punishment seems pretty lenient considering how seriously they thought he'd been violating their laws, though. "Sure, keep on doing your interfering, just... limit it to this general place and time." It also stretched credulity that these master of space and time who had the power to choose his next appearance could only show the possibilities as crude sketches. | |||
Jamie and Zoe being returned to where they'd been taken from with their memories wiped feels a lot like what happened with Donna decades later, though they didn't have lives and personalities as lacking as she did pre-Doctor. | |||
Goodbye Troughton. Goodbye 1960s. Goodbye black & white. | |||
---- | ---- | ||